aboutsummaryrefslogtreecommitdiff
path: root/reproduce/analysis/config
AgeCommit message (Collapse)AuthorLines
2021-06-08Minor edits suggested by David and updating of Zenodo DOIMohammad Akhlaghi-1/+1
David made suggested some minor edits that are now implemented (most importantly that he would not like to be associated with an ORCID ID). I also "saved" a new Zenodo DOI for the final submission of this paper to Zenodo, but "after" obtaining the page number information and other minor things.
2021-04-17Imported recent work in Maneage, minor conflicts fixedMohammad Akhlaghi-3/+18
Some minor conflicts (all expected from the commit messages in the Maneage branch) occurred but were easily fixed.
2021-04-17IMPORTANT: print-general-metadata new name for print-copyrightMohammad Akhlaghi-3/+18
Summary: - Use the new name of this variable in your Makefiles. - In 'metadata.conf', remove fixed URL prefixes for DOIs ('https://doi.org/') or arXiv ('https://arxiv.org/abs'). Until now, the Make variable that would print the general metadata (of whole project) into each to-be-published dataset was called 'print-copyright'! But it now does much more than simply printing the copyright, it will also print a lot of metadata like arXiv ID, Zenodo DOI and etc into plain-text outputs. The out-dated name could thus be misleading and cause confusions. With this commit, the variable is therefore called 'print-general-metadata'. After merging your project with the Maneage branch, please replace any usage of 'print-copyright' to 'print-general-metadata'. Also with this commit, 'README-hacking.md' mentions 'metadata.conf' and 'print-general-metadata' in the "Publication checklist" section and reminds you to keep the first up to date, and use the second in your to-be-published datasets.
2021-04-17Finally published journal DOI addedMohammad Akhlaghi-4/+4
In the project's 'metadata.conf', we also have an option to store the journal DOI of the project (that will later be printed in the output file products). So now that the paper's DOI has been set by the journal, it was time to add it in the project too. While looking at the usage of the metadata, I noticed that the "Publication checklist" of 'README-hacking.md' didn't talk about it. In fact, the part about putting metadata went into a lot of detail without even mentioning the generic 'print-general-metadata' variable (previously called 'print-copyright') that is created in 'initialize.mk'. So I removed those extra points and just recommended using this variable for plain-text files and putting similar info in other formats. Some other minor changes were made: - The metadata now doesn't need the fixed 'https://doi.org/' prefix (to make it consistent with the arXiv identifier). Inside 'initialize.mk', there are now two variables called 'doi-prefix-url' and 'arxiv-prefix-url' that contain the fixed prefix. - The 'print-copyright' name was clearly outdated for all the extra metadata that this variable created (including the copyright). So its name was changed to 'print-general-metadata'. The generic Maneage changes will be taken into Maneage after this (they were tested here).
2021-04-09Changed all gitlab.com URLs to git.maneage.orgMohammad Akhlaghi-1/+1
Until now, we were primarily linking people to the Gitlab fork of this paper. However, since this paper is part of Maneage, its main repository is on Maneage's own server at http://git.maneage.org/paper-concept.git With this commit therefore, all the gitlab.com URLs have been corrected to owr own Git server. While looking into Git-related points, I also noticed that in the demo code listing showing how to clone Maneage and start a new project, we were using Git's old/depreciated 'master' name. Git (and almost all common repositories) now use 'main' as the default branch name, so this has also been corrected here.
2021-01-03Imported recent updates in Maneage, minor conflicts fixedMohammad Akhlaghi-4/+4
There were only three very small conflicts that have been fixed.
2021-01-02Copyright year updated in all source filesMohammad Akhlaghi-5/+5
Having entered 2021, it was necessary to update the copyright years at the top of the source files. We recommend that you do this for all your project-specific source files also.
2020-12-01Imported recent work in Maneage, minor conflicts fixedMohammad Akhlaghi-133/+5
Some minor conflicts that came up during the merge were fixed.
2020-11-26All the referee points have been answeredMohammad Akhlaghi-1/+1
There is an answer for all the referee points now. I also did some minor edits in the paper. But we are still over the limit by around 250 words. The only remaining point that is not yet addressed (and has '####' around it) is the discussion on parallelization and its effect on reproducibility.
2020-11-23Minor edits and correctionsMohammad Akhlaghi-1/+1
Raul's added point on the answer to the referee was very good, so I edited it a little to be more clear (and removed his name). Also, after looking in a few parts of the text, I fixed a few typos.
2020-11-23First draft of all the points addressed by the refereesMohammad Akhlaghi-1/+1
A new directory has been added at the top of the project's source called 'peer-review'. The raw reviews of the paper by the editors and referees has been added there as '1-review.txt'. All the main points raised by the referees have been listed in a numbered list and addressed (mostly) in '1-answers.txt'. The text of the paper now also includes all the implemented answers to the various points.
2020-11-15Building final PDF: pdf-build-final has to be given an explicit yesMohammad Akhlaghi-5/+5
Until now, when the 'pdf-build-final' configuration variable (defined in 'reproduce/analysis/config/pdf-build.conf') was given any string a PDF would be built. This was very confusing, because people could put a 'no' and the PDF would still be built! With this commit, only when this variable has a value of 'yes' will the PDF be built. If given any other string (or no string at all), it will not produce a PDF. This issue was reported by Zahra Sharbaf.
2020-09-24Gnuastro's analysis configuration files removedMohammad Akhlaghi-128/+0
Until now, the core Maneage branch included some configuration files for Gnuastro's programs. This was actually a remnant of the distant past when Maneage didn't actually build its own software and we had to rely on the host's software versions. This file contained the configuration files specific to Gnuastro for this project and also had a feature to avoid checking the host's own configuration files. However, we now build all our software ourselves with fixed configuration files (for the version that is being installed and its version is stored). So those extra configuration files were just extra and caused confusion and problems in some scenarios. With this commit, those extra files are now removed. Also, two small issues are also addressed in parallel with this commit: - When running './project make clean', the 'hardware-parameters.tex' macro file (which is created by './project configure' is not deleted. - The project title is now written into the default output's PDF's properties (through 'hypersetup' in 'tex/src/preamble-header.tex') through the LaTeX macro. All these issues were found and fixed with the help of Samane Raji.
2020-08-20Imported recent updates in Maneage, minor conflicts fixedMohammad Akhlaghi-14/+23
Some very minor conflicts came up and were easily corrected. They were mostly in parts that are also shared with the demonstration in the core Maneage branch.
2020-07-04Better names and comments in INPUTS.confMohammad Akhlaghi-20/+23
Until now, the dataset's configuration names had a 'WFPC2' prefix. But this very alien to anyone that is not familiar with the history of the Hubble Space Telescope (the camera is no longer used! Its just used here since its one of the standard FITS files from the FITS standard webpage). With this commit the variable names have been modified to be more readable and clear (having a 'DEMO-' prefix). Also the comments of 'INPUTS.conf' (describing the purpose of each variable) were edited and made more clear.
2020-06-28Zenodo identifier is extracted automatically from metadata.confMohammad Akhlaghi-1/+1
Until now, the Zenodo identifier was manually written in the paper. But now we have the Zenodo DOI in 'metadata.conf', so its much more robust to get it from there (in case updated versions of the paper is published).
2020-06-10Corrected bug in using local copy of input datasetMohammad Akhlaghi-2/+32
As described in Maneage's commit 2bd2e2f18 (which I found while testing this project), the existing download recipe had problems when using a local copy of the input dataset. It was first fixed here, then implemented there. Also, to clarify things for a new user, some long comments were added at the top of 'INPUTS.conf' to describe each of the variables, that comment has also been put here (and is also in commit 2bd2e2f18 of Maneage).
2020-06-10IMPORTANT: bug fix in default data download script of download.mkMohammad Akhlaghi-3/+39
Summary of possible semantic conflicts 1. The recipe to download input datasets has been modified. You have to re-set the old 'origname' variable to 'localname' (to avoid confusion) and the default dataset URL should now be complete (including the actual filename). See the newly added descriptions in 'INPUTS.conf' for more on this. Until now, when the dataset was already present on the host system, a link couldn't be made to it, causing the project to crash in the checksum phase. This has been fixed with properly naming the main variable as 'localname' to avoid the confusion that caused it. Some other problems have been fixed in this recipe in the meantime: - When the checksum is different, the expected and calculated checksums are printed. - In the default paper, we now print the full URL of the dataset, not just the server, so the checksum of the 'download.tex' step has been updated.
2020-06-09Imported Maneage, minor conflicts fixed, a bug found and fixedMohammad Akhlaghi-16/+25
Some minor conflicts came up in 'initialize.mk' and 'verify.mk'. For the former, I chose the version on Maneage, for the latter, I kept the 'master' version on the checksums of this project, but kept the Maneage version for the rest of the improvements there (like printing the verified files as LaTeX comments in 'verify.tex'. While testing the conflicts, I noticed a bug (in the LaTeX macro for the number of years in the Menke+20 paper) in the previous build, thanks to the verification step :-)! Fortunately it wasn't actually printed in the PDF, so a normal reader won't recognize. The bug was caused by the recently added meta-data/commented lines in the 'tools-per-year.txt' file: when calculating the number of years studied in that paper, we were simply counting all the lines and we had forgot to correct this after adding comments. As a result, the un-used LaTeX macro file was saying that they have studied 47 years instead of the real 31 years! This element was actually used in the very first (+40 page!) draft of the paper that was summarized to fit into the journal limits.
2020-06-06IMPORTANT: Added publication checklist, improved relevant infrastructureMohammad Akhlaghi-1/+26
Possible semantic conflicts (that may not show up as Git conflicts but may cause a crash in your project after the merge): 1) The project title (and other basic metadata) should be set in 'reproduce/analysis/conf/metadata.conf'. Please include this file in your merge (if it is ignored because of '.gitattributes'!). 2) Consider importing the changes in 'initialize.mk' and 'verify.mk' (if you have added all analysis Makefiles to the '.gitattributes' file (thus not merging any change in them with your branch). For example with this command: git diff master...maneage -- reproduce/analysis/make/initialize.mk 3) The old 'verify-txt-no-comments-leading-space' function has been replaced by 'verify-txt-no-comments-no-space'. The new function will also remove all white-space characters between the columns (not just white space characters at the start of the line). Thus the resulting check won't involve spacing between columns. A common set of steps are always necessary to prepare a project for publication. Until now, we would simply look at previous submissions and try to follow them, but that was prone to errors and could cause confusion. The internal infrastructure also didn't have some useful features to make good publication possible. Now that the submission of a paper fully devoted to the founding criteria of Maneage is complete (arXiv:2006.03018), it was time to formalize the necessary steps for easier submission of a project using Maneage and implement some low-level features that can make things easier. With this commit a first draft of the publication checklist has been added to 'README-hacking.md', it was tested in the submission of arXiv:2006.03018 and zenodo.3872248. To help guide users on implementing the good practices for output datasets, the outputs of the default project shown in the paper now use the new features). After reading the checklist, please inspect these. Some other relevant changes in this commit: - The publication involves a copy of the necessary software tarballs. Hence a new target ('dist-software') was also added to package all the project's software tarballs in one tarball for easy distribution. - A new 'dist-lzip' target has been defined for those who want to distribute an Lzip-compressed tarball. - The '\includetikz' LaTeX macro now has a second argument to allow configuring the '\includegraphics' call when the plot should not be built, but just imported.
2020-06-04Verification activated, README added, Proper metadata in plot dataMohammad Akhlaghi-2/+25
All the steps following the to-be-added (in 'README-hacking.md') publication checklist prior to the final check from new clone have been added: - 'README.md' file has been set. - "Reproducible supplement" was added just above the keywords, pointing to Zenodo. - A link to the to-be-uploaded data underlying the plot was added in the caption of the tools-per-year plot. - A new meta-data configuration file was added to store basic project metadata to be used throughout the project. This will later be taken into Maneage. For examle the project title is now stored here and written into the paper's LaTeX source and output datasets automatically. - Verification was activated and plot's data and LaTeX macro files are now automatically verified. - A complete metadata was added for the data underlying the plot. - A generic function was added in 'initialize.mk' that will automatically write project info and copyright in all plain-text outputs.
2020-05-22Corrected copyright notices to fit GPL suggested formatMohammad Akhlaghi-2/+16
In time, some of the copyright license description had been mistakenly shortened to two paragraphs instead of the original three that is recommended in the GPL. With this commit, they are corrected to be exactly in the same three paragraph format suggested by GPL. The following files also didn't have a copyright notice, so one was added for them: reproduce/software/make/README.md reproduce/software/bibtex/healpix.tex reproduce/analysis/config/delete-me-num.conf reproduce/analysis/config/verify-outputs.conf
2020-05-22Re-write of the paper to fit in ~6000 words and IEEE formatMohammad Akhlaghi-0/+0
Following the fact that the DSJ editor decided that this paper doesn't fit into their scope, we decided to submit it to IEEE's Computing in Science and Engineering (CiSE). So with this commit the text was re-written to fit into their style and word-count limitations.
2020-05-01Imported recent changes in Maneage, minor conflicts fixedMohammad Akhlaghi-1/+1
A few small conflicts showed up here and there. They are fixed with this merge.
2020-04-26verify-outputs.conf: typo correction in comment to avoid confusionBoud Roukema-1/+1
Until now, the comment in the file said that setting the `verify-outputs` variable to `yes` disables the verification. Looking at `reproduce/analysis/make/verify.mk` shows that the opposite is true. With this commit, the word `disable` is replaced with `enable` so that the user is not confused by the conflict between the source code in the other file and this comment.
2020-04-17Imported recent work in Maneage, minor conflicts fixedMohammad Akhlaghi-0/+128
A few minor conflicts came up that were easily fixed.
2020-04-17IMPORTANT: software config directly under reproduce/software/configMohammad Akhlaghi-0/+128
Until now the software configuration parameters were defined under the `reproduce/software/config/installation/' directory. This was because the configuration parameters of analysis software (for example Gnuastro's configurations) were placed under there too. But this was terribly confusing, because the run-time options of programs falls under the "analysis" phase of the project. With this commit, the Gnuastro configuration files have been moved under the new `reproduce/analysis/config/gnuastro' directory and the software configuration files are directly under `reproduce/software/config'. A clean build was done with this change and it didn't crash, but it may cause crashes in derived projects, so after merging with Maneage, please re-configure your project to see if anything has been missed. Please let us know if there is a problem.
2020-04-02Imported recent work on Maneage, minor conflicts fixedMohammad Akhlaghi-1/+0
A few minor conflicts occurred and were fixed.
2020-03-23Analysis and configuration file sections completeMohammad Akhlaghi-0/+3
With this commit a description of these two important parts have been added to the project, along with several figures showing various parts of the files that are discussed. I also done some other restructuring of the figures and files to make things fit better into the the description of the paper.
2020-03-02Described the first analysis phase with a demo subMakefileMohammad Akhlaghi-1/+1
Until now, there was no explanation on an actual analysis phase, therefore with this commit an example scenario with a readable Makefile is included. The Data lineage graph was also simplified to both be more readable, and also to correspond to this new explanation and subMakefile. Some random edits/typos were also corrected and some references added for discussion.
2020-02-16Menke+2020 data is now imported and ready for later steps in plain textMohammad Akhlaghi-4/+4
The main problems with this dataset was the names of the journals (which sometimes have single quotes or apostrophes in them that is really annoying for SED)! But ultimately, for the simple study we want to do here, the journal names are irrelevant, so in the end I just ignored the names. Later we can set an identifier for the journals if necessary. But now we have the basic information in a way that is usable in a plot to show in this paper.
2020-01-20IMPORTANT!!! Configuration Makefiles now have a .conf suffixMohammad Akhlaghi-1/+0
Until now, the configuration Makefiles (in `reproduce/software/config/installation' and `reproduce/analysis/config') had a `.mk' suffix, similar to the workhorse Makefiles. Although they are indeed Makefiles, but given their nature (to only keep configuration parameters), it is confusing (especially to early users) for them to also have a `.mk' (similar to the analysis or software building Makefiles). To address this issue, with this commit, all the configuration Makefiles (in those directories) are now given a `.conf' suffix. This is also assumed for all the files that are loaded. The configuration (software building) and running of the template have been checked with this change from scratch, but please report any error that may not have been noticed. THIS IS AN IMPORTANT CHANGE AND WILL CAUSE CRASHES OR UNEXPECTED BEHAVIORS FOR PROJECTS THAT HAVE BRANCHED FROM THIS TEMPLATE. PLEASE CORRECT THE SUFFIX OF ALL YOUR PROJECT'S CONFIGURATION MAKEFILES (IN THE DIRECTORIES ABOVE), OTHERWISE THEY AREN'T AUTOMATICALLY LOADED ANYMORE.
2020-01-18First set of customizations doneMohammad Akhlaghi-3/+1
The unnecessary parts were removed and the project now runs.
2020-01-01Verification of output values and data added within templateMohammad Akhlaghi-0/+3
Until now, the only verification that the template provided was the published PDF. Users had to manually compare the published and generated PDFs (numbers, plots, tables) and see if they obtained the same result. However, this type of manual verification is not good and is prone to frustration and missing important differences. With this commit, a new Makefile has been added in the analysis steps: `verify.mk'. It provides facilities to easily verify the results that go into the paper. For example tables that go into making the paper's plots, or the LaTeX macros that blend into the text. See the updated parts in `README-hacking.md` for a more complete explanation. This completes task #15497.
2020-01-01Copyright statements updated to include 2020Mohammad Akhlaghi-2/+2
Now that its 2020, its necessary to include this year in the copyright statements.
2019-06-29Added citation for TIDES, sorted progs alphabeticallyMohammad Akhlaghi-1/+1
While reviewing Prasenjit's commits, I noticed that we had forgot to add the citation for TIDES, also to make things clear, the program/library build rules are now sorted alphabetically. Finally, I noticed that after building the TiKZ PDF figures, it is crashing (like on Prasenjit's computer). After looking around, I noticed its because we were setting the of the `TEXINPUTS' environment variable to be the installed TeX Live directory (which was ultimately redundant because by default TeX will look into where it was installed). The important thing is just that we remove any possible value the host system has, not to set new directories.
2019-06-28tides library addedPrasenjit Saha-1/+1
TIDES is an ODE integrator with multiple-precision arithmetic.
2019-04-15New architecture to separate software-building and analysis stepsMohammad Akhlaghi-0/+38
Until now, the software building and analysis steps of the pipeline were intertwined. However, these steps (of how to build a software, and how to use it) are logically completely independent. Therefore with this commit, the pipeline now has a new architecture (particularly in the `reproduce' directory) to emphasize this distinction: The `reproduce' directory now has the two `software' and `analysis' subdirectories and the respective parts of the previous architecture have been broken up between these two based on their function. There is also no more `src' directory. The `config' directory for software and analysis is now mixed with the language-specific directories. Also, some of the software versions were also updated after some checks with their webpages. This new architecture will allow much more focused work on each part of the pipeline (to install the software and to run them for an analysis).